Jennifer Lopez has confirmed that she turned down the erotic thriller Unfaithful, and in 2026 the decision remains one of the most discussed what-ifs of her film career. During a candid conversation on The Howard Stern Show, the star said that director Adrian Lyne offered her the 2002 movie, which ultimately starred Richard Gere and Diane Lane. Lopez explained that she passed because she did not believe the script was strong, even though she now credits Lyne with making the final film work.

jennifer-lopez-still-regrets-passing-on-unfaithful-as-oscar-what-if-lingers-image-0

The admission carries extra weight because Unfaithful became a significant showcase for Diane Lane. Directed by Lyne, the film follows a suburban New York couple whose marriage spirals into dangerous territory after the wife begins an affair. Lane earned a Best Actress nomination at the Academy Awards for her performance, the film’s only Oscar recognition, and she ultimately lost to Nicole Kidman for The Hours. For Lopez, the contrast between her judgment of the screenplay and the finished film’s awards profile is the source of the regret.

“It’s funny. It haunts me. It haunts me a little bit,” Lopez said, according to the Howard Stern conversation. “It’s like the one that I turned down that it was just like, ‘Why did you turn down working with Adrian Lyne? What were you thinking?’ I didn’t even know what the hell was going on in my mind at the time. Who knows what was going on with me at the time.”

A Hit With Viewers, if Not With Every Critic

Unfaithful was not a universal critical favorite, but it connected with audiences. The film grossed $119 million worldwide and has a mixed 51% critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes alongside a stronger 68% Popcornmeter score. Those numbers help explain why the role has stayed in Lopez’s mind: it was both a commercial success and an actor’s showcase.

Metric Result
Worldwide gross $119 million
Rotten Tomatoes critics’ score 51%
Popcornmeter 68%
Oscar recognition Diane Lane, Best Actress nomination

jennifer-lopez-still-regrets-passing-on-unfaithful-as-oscar-what-if-lingers-image-1

The Road Not Taken in a Busy 2002 Slate

Around the time Unfaithful arrived, Lopez was working steadily in films such as The Wedding Planner (2001), Angel Eyes (2001), Enough (2002) and Maid in Manhattan (2002). She also starred opposite Ben Affleck in Gigli (2002), a box office bomb that remains one of the most notorious missteps of either star’s career. The comparison is not entirely fair — Lopez was building a rom-com and pop-culture brand while Lane was anchoring a darker adult drama — but it illustrates why the Unfaithful what-if still resonates. 🎬

A New Awards Conversation With Kiss of the Spider Woman

In October 2025, Lopez returned to the awards conversation with Kiss of the Spider Woman, Bill Condon’s musical drama co-starring Diego Luna. The film drew generally positive reviews, and Lopez’s supporting turn was repeatedly singled out as a highlight. A ScreenRant review gave the film 7 out of 10, praising its performances and musical numbers while noting uneven story and tone elements. The review said Lopez steals the show as Luna’s character plays Aurora and the Spider Woman, describing her as stunning, beguiling, confident and thrilling. 🏆

“Lopez is everything Molina describes Ingrid to be: stunning, beguiling, confident, and thrilling,” the review said.

As of 2026, Lopez still has not received an Academy Award nomination or win, but the positive reception for Kiss of the Spider Woman has renewed speculation about whether that could change. Her recent filmography has been mixed: Unstoppable (2024) was generally well received, Atlas (2024) was a critical dud, and The Mother (2023) became a major Netflix viewership success despite weak reviews. This Is Me... Now: A Love Story (2024) and Shotgun Wedding (2022) also kept her in the public conversation.

For Lopez, Unfaithful remains a lingering regret, but it is not the whole story. The star has continued to find success with viewers, and the response to Kiss of the Spider Woman suggests that her Oscar moment may still be ahead. In 2026, the Unfaithful what-if is less a cautionary tale than a reminder that even a missed opportunity can become part of a long, unpredictable career.